Logarithmic measure of effective sound pressure relative to a reference value.
Lp=20log10(prefprms) dB
prms = root mean square sound pressure
pref = reference sound pressure
Medium
Reference Pressure
Notes
Air
pref=20μPa
Threshold of human hearing at 1 kHz
Water
pref=1μPa
Underwater acoustics standard (ISO)
Conversion: To convert air SPL to water SPL scale: add 26 dB (since 20log10(20/1)=26). Note: This is only a reference shift, not a physical equivalence.
Wave Equation
Governs propagation of acoustic pressure disturbances through a medium.
∇2p−c21∂t2∂2p=0
1D Form
∂x2∂2p=c21∂t2∂2p
Speed of Sound
c=MγRT≈343 m/s
at 20°C in air
p = acoustic pressure (Pa)
c = speed of sound (m/s)
∇2 = Laplacian operator
Plane Wave Solution:p(x,t)=Aei(ωt−kx)+Bei(ωt+kx) where k=ω/c is the wavenumber.
Ref: Kinsler et al. "Fundamentals of Acoustics" Wiley 2000; Beranek & Mellow "Acoustics: Sound Fields and Transducers" Academic Press 2012
Yields n natural frequencies ωn,i and mode shapes {ϕi}.
Damping Treatment: The eigenvalue problem is solved for the undamped system (C=0). Damping is typically added later via modal damping ratios ζi assigned to each mode, or through proportional (Rayleigh) damping: [C]=α[M]+β[K] where ζi=2ωiα+2βωi.
Modal Superposition
Transform to modal coordinates {q}:
{x}=[Φ]{q}
Where [Φ] = modal matrix (columns are mode shapes).
Modal Coordinates qi: Each qi(t) is a scalar "participation factor" that scales how much mode i contributes to the total response at time t. Physical displacement = sum of mode shapes weighted by their modal coordinates.
A mode shape {ϕi} describes the relative displacement pattern when the system vibrates at frequency ωn,i.
Amplitude meaning: Only the ratio between DOFs matters, not absolute values. Mode shapes are typically normalized (mass-normalized: {ϕ}T[M]{ϕ}=1, or max=1.0).
Sign: Positive/negative indicates in-phase/out-of-phase motion between DOFs.
Zero crossings: Nodes where that DOF has no motion for that mode.
Ref: Meirovitch "Fundamentals of Vibrations" McGraw-Hill 2001; Ewins "Modal Testing: Theory, Practice and Application" Wiley 2000
Estimates RMS response of SDOF system to flat random input.
x¨rms=2πfnQ⋅ASD(fn)
Assumptions:
Flat input spectrum near fn
Light damping
SDOF response dominated by resonance
G-RMS from PSD
Overall RMS acceleration computed by integrating the PSD over frequency.
Grms=∫f1f2PSD(f)df
Trapezoidal Integration (Log-Log):
Grms2=∑i=1n−12(fi+1−fi)(PSDi+PSDi+1)
For log-log interpolation, use geometric mean approach for more accurate results.
Velocity PSD
PSDv=(2πf)2PSDa
Displacement PSD
PSDd=(2πf)4PSDa
Note: Convert g² to (in/s²)² or (m/s²)² before integrating for velocity/displacement.
Ref: Bendat & Piersol "Random Data" Wiley 2010; Newland "An Introduction to Random Vibrations" Dover 2005
07. Vibration Statistics
Distributions
Type
Description
Kurtosis
Gaussian
Random vibration instantaneous values.
3.0
Rayleigh
Peak values of narrowband random.
-
Sine
Harmonic vibration ("Bathtub" PDF).
1.5
Sigma (σ) Peaks
Probability of exceeding nσ in Gaussian process:
1σ 68.27%
2σ 95.45%
3σ 99.73%
Ref: Wirsching et al. "Random Vibrations: Theory and Practice" Dover 2006
08. VRS & Extreme Response Spectrum
Vibration Response Spectrum (VRS)
Plot of the RMS response of a series of SDOF oscillators to a random input.
VRSrms(fn)=∫0∞∣H(f,fn)∣2⋅PSD(f)df
Term
Definition
Units
VRSrms(fn)
RMS response at natural frequency fn
g (or m/s²)
H(f,fn)
SDOF transfer function (DMF)
dimensionless
PSD(f)
Input Power Spectral Density
g²/Hz
Extreme Response Spectrum (ERS)
Estimates the maximum expected peak response over a duration T.
ERS(fn)=σrms(fn)⋅2ln(ν0T)
σrms = RMS Response (from VRS)
ν0≈fn = Zero-crossing rate
T = Exposure duration (seconds)
Role of Sigma: The term 2ln(ν0T) represents the "Peak Factor" (number of sigmas). As time T increases, the probability of seeing a higher sigma peak increases.
Ref: Irvine "VRS and ERS" vibrationdata.com 2012; Lalanne "Mechanical Vibration and Shock Analysis Vol. 3" Wiley 2014
Spatial correlation describes how pressure fluctuations at two points relate to each other. A correlation of 1 means perfectly in-phase (coherent), 0 means uncorrelated (random phase). Why it matters: Correlated pressures add constructively, producing higher structural response than uncorrelated pressures of the same magnitude. Accurate correlation modeling is critical for predicting vibration response to distributed acoustic and aerodynamic loads.
Turbulent Boundary Layer (TBL)
Fluctuating pressure on surface due to flow.
Φpp(ω)≈U∞q2δ∗⋅F(ωδ∗/U∞)
q = Dynamic Pressure
δ∗ = Displacement Thickness
Used for: Aircraft fuselage, fairings, high-speed trains.
TBL Correlation: Corcos Model
Spatial correlation of TBL pressure fluctuations:
Γ(ξ,η,ω)=e−∣ξ∣/Lxe−∣η∣/Lye−iωξ/Uc
ξ,η = Streamwise, spanwise separation
Lx=Uc/αxω, Ly=Uc/αyω (correlation lengths)
αx≈0.1, αy≈0.7 (Corcos constants)
Uc≈0.6−0.8U∞ (convection velocity)
Physical interpretation: TBL correlation decays exponentially with separation distance. Correlation length decreases with frequency (high-freq eddies are smaller). Streamwise correlation is higher than spanwise due to convecting turbulent structures. The phase term e−iωξ/Uc captures the convection of pressure patterns downstream.
Diffuse Acoustic Field (DAF)
Uniform acoustic energy arriving from all directions with random phase.
prms2=A4Wρc
W = Source Power (W)
A = Total Absorption (m² Sabins)
DAF Spatial Correlation
Correlation between two points in a diffuse acoustic field:
Γ(r)=krsin(kr)
r = Separation distance between points
k=ω/c=2πf/c = Acoustic wavenumber
Γ(0)=1 (perfect correlation at same point)
First zero at r=λ/2 (half wavelength)
Physical interpretation: DAF correlation follows a sinc function, oscillating and decaying with distance. Unlike TBL, DAF has no preferred direction—correlation depends only on separation distance, not orientation. Points separated by half a wavelength are uncorrelated. At low frequencies (large λ), correlation extends over larger areas, causing more efficient structural excitation.
Correlation Comparison
Property
TBL (Corcos)
DAF
Decay Shape
Exponential
Sinc (oscillating)
Directional?
Yes (anisotropic)
No (isotropic)
Convection
Yes (phase shift)
No
Corr. Length
∝1/ω
∝λ
Ref: Corcos "Resolution of Pressure in Turbulence" JASA 1963; Blake "Mechanics of Flow-Induced Sound and Vibration" Academic Press 2017; Fahy "Sound and Structural Vibration" 2007; ESI VA One User Guide
Rule of Thumb: Element size Le≤λmin/N where N = 6-10 for linear, 3-4 for quadratic elements.
Wave Types & Speeds
Wave Type
Speed Equation
Dispersive?
Longitudinal
cL=E/ρ
No
Shear
cS=G/ρ
No
Bending
cB=4EIω2/(ρA)
Yes
Rayleigh
cR≈0.92cS
No
Torsional*
cT=G/ρ
No*
*Torsional waves are dispersive for non-circular cross-sections due to warping effects.
Critical Bending Wavelength
Bending waves are dispersive (speed varies with frequency). At max frequency:
λB=2π4ρAωmax2EI
For plates: λB=2π4ρhωmax2D where D=12(1−ν2)Eh3
Ref: Langer et al. "More Than Six Elements Per Wavelength" J. Comput. Acoust. 2017; Petyt "Introduction to Finite Element Vibration Analysis" Cambridge 2010
14. DSP & Data Acquisition
Sampling & Aliasing
fs>2fmax (Nyquist Criterion)
Frequencies above fs/2 fold back (alias) into the baseband.
Dynamic Range & Bit Depth
SNRdB≈6.02N+1.76
N = Number of Bits
16-bit ≈ 96 dB
24-bit ≈ 144 dB
Window Functions
Window
Use Case
Trade-off
Hanning
Random Vib / General
Good amplitude, fair freq
Flat Top
Calibration / Sine
Best amplitude, poor freq
Rectangular
Transients / Impact
Best freq, leakage risk
Ref: Oppenheim & Schafer "Discrete-Time Signal Processing" Pearson 2009; Harris "On the Use of Windows for Harmonic Analysis" Proc. IEEE 1978
Consider transient operation through critical speeds
Evaluate blade pass frequency interactions
Account for temperature effects on material properties
Shaft Speed to Frequency:
fHz=60ΩRPM
Blade Pass Frequency:
fBP=nblades⋅60ΩRPM
Design Guidance: API 617 (compressors) requires critical speeds to be at least 15% away from operating speed range. For transient operation, ensure adequate damping or rapid acceleration through critical speeds.
Ref: API 617 "Axial and Centrifugal Compressors"; Childs, "Turbomachinery Rotordynamics" Wiley 1993; Vance, "Rotordynamics of Turbomachinery" Wiley 1988
21. PSD Calculation from Time History
Welch's Method Overview
Standard approach for estimating PSD from sampled time data using averaged periodograms.
Preprocess: Remove mean, apply detrending, filter if needed
Segment: Divide time history into overlapping frames (typ. 50% overlap)
Window: Apply window function (e.g., Hanning) to each segment
FFT: Compute FFT for each windowed segment: Xk=∑n=0N−1xn⋅e−j2πkn/N
Power: Calculate |Xk|² for each segment
Average: Average the power spectra across all segments
Scale to PSD: Convert to single-sided PSD with window energy correction:
Sxx(fk)=fs⋅N2⋅CE2⋅∣Xk∣2
where CE = window energy correction factor (see table below), fs = sample rate, N = FFT length. Factor of 2 converts to single-sided (positive frequencies only). For Hanning window, CE = 1.63.
Key Parameters
Parameter
Formula
Notes
Frequency Resolution
Δf=T1=Nfs
T = segment duration, N = samples/segment
Segment Duration
T=fsN
Longer T → finer Δf but fewer averages
Nyquist Frequency
fmax=2fs
Maximum resolvable frequency
N for desired Δf
N=Δffs
Must be power of 2 for efficient FFT
Example: For fs = 4000 Hz and desired Δf = 5 Hz:
N=54000=800 samples → Use N = 1024 (next power of 2) → actual Δf = 3.9 Hz
Segment duration T = 1024/4000 = 0.256 seconds
Time vs. Frequency Resolution Trade-off
Fundamental trade-off: finer frequency resolution requires longer segments, reducing time resolution and number of averages.
Δf⋅T=1
The uncertainty principle: cannot have arbitrarily fine resolution in both domains simultaneously.
Δf
Segment T
Pros
Cons
1 Hz
1.0 sec
Fine frequency detail, resolves closely-spaced peaks
Fewer averages, higher variance, poor for short events
5 Hz
0.2 sec
Good balance for most applications
May not resolve narrow-band features
25 Hz
0.04 sec
Many averages, low variance, captures transients
Smears frequency content, poor peak resolution
SMC-S-016 Flight Data Processing
Per SMC-S-016 "Test Requirements for Launch, Upper-Stage, and Space Vehicles":
Segment Duration: "Use 1-second time segments" for computing PSDs from flight data
Overlap: "50% overlap between adjacent segments" to maximize statistical DOF
Bandwidth: 5 Hz constant bandwidth with conversion to 1/6th octave bands for final presentation (no need to go narrower than 5 Hz at low frequencies)
Window: Hanning window recommended to reduce spectral leakage
Window Functions
Windows reduce spectral leakage from discontinuities at segment boundaries. Each window trades off main lobe width vs. side lobe suppression.
Window
Amp. Corr.
Energy Corr.
ENBW
Use Case
Rectangular
1.00
1.00
1.00
Transients (full capture)
Hanning
2.00
1.63
1.50
Random vibration (most common)
Hamming
1.85
1.59
1.36
General purpose
Blackman
2.80
1.97
1.73
Low leakage required
Flat Top
4.18
2.26
3.77
Amplitude accuracy (calibration)
ENBW = Equivalent Noise Bandwidth (in frequency bins). For PSD, apply energy correction.
Overlap & Degrees of Freedom
Overlap reuses data between segments, increasing effective DOF for the same total duration.
Overlap
DOF per Frame
Efficiency
Notes
0%
2.00
100%
No data reuse
50%
~1.85
~185%
Optimal for Hanning window
75%
~1.20
~240%
Diminishing returns
DOF Formula:
nDOF≈2⋅navg⋅ηoverlap
where navg = number of averaged segments, ηoverlap = overlap efficiency factor
Subtract DC offset to prevent low-frequency bias. Critical before windowing as DC leaks into adjacent bins.
Detrending
Remove linear/polynomial trends from sensor drift. Use least-squares fit for polynomial order 1-3.
Anti-Alias Filter
Applied during acquisition. Cutoff fc = 0.4–0.45 × fs typical. Use steep rolloff (8th order Butterworth or better) to ensure >80 dB attenuation at Nyquist.
Highpass Filter
Remove content below analysis band. Set cutoff at 0.5–1× lowest frequency of interest. Use 4th order Butterworth (24 dB/octave) minimum.
Anti-Aliasing Filter Selection
Rule of thumb: fc = 0.4 × fs provides margin for filter rolloff.
Sample Rate (fs)
Recommended Cutoff
Usable Bandwidth
1,000 Hz
400 Hz
5–400 Hz
4,000 Hz
1,600 Hz
5–1,600 Hz
10,000 Hz
4,000 Hz
5–4,000 Hz
50,000 Hz
20,000 Hz
5–20,000 Hz
Higher order filters allow cutoff closer to Nyquist but introduce phase distortion. For shock/transient data, use linear-phase (FIR) filters.
DC & Low-Frequency Handling
DC Offset: Always remove mean before FFT. Even small DC offsets create large low-frequency artifacts due to spectral leakage.
Sensor Drift: Accelerometers exhibit 1/f noise below ~5 Hz. Apply highpass filter or discard bins below analysis band.
Integration Effects: When integrating acceleration to velocity/displacement, DC and low-frequency errors accumulate. Highpass filter before integration.
Recommended Practice: Set analysis lower bound at 5–10 Hz for typical accelerometer data unless sensor is specifically rated for lower frequencies.
Key Insight: The choice of segment length is the primary trade-off. Longer segments give finer frequency resolution but fewer averages (higher variance). For stationary signals, use longer segments. For non-stationary or transient data, use shorter segments to capture time-varying behavior.
Ref: Bendat & Piersol "Random Data" Wiley 2010; SMC-S-016 (2014) "Test Requirements for Launch Vehicles" Section 6.2.3; Welch "The Use of FFT for Estimation of Power Spectra" IEEE 1967; Harris "On the Use of Windows" Proc. IEEE 1978
The Shock Response Spectrum (SRS) characterizes a transient's potential to excite resonant structures. It plots the peak response of an array of single degree-of-freedom (SDOF) oscillators, each with a different natural frequency but the same damping ratio, when subjected to the same base excitation.
Key concept: The SRS does not contain all information about the original time history—many different transients can produce the same SRS. It captures only the peak instantaneous responses at each frequency.
Smallwood Ramp Invariant Algorithm
The most widely used SRS calculation method is the ramp invariant digital recursive filter developed by David O. Smallwood (1981). This method connects impulse-response samples with straight lines to reduce aliasing errors.
Algorithm Steps:
Define Parameters: Set damping ratio ξ (typically 5%, Q=10) and analysis frequencies
Design Filter: For each natural frequency fn, compute ramp invariant filter coefficients
Apply Filter: Process the acceleration time history through each SDOF digital filter
Extract Peaks: Record maximum positive, negative, and absolute (maximax) responses
Build Spectrum: Plot peak response vs. natural frequency on log-log axes
SDOF Response Equation
Each oscillator in the SRS bank follows the equation of motion:
z¨+2ζωnz˙+ωn2z=−x¨base
where z = relative displacement, ωn = 2πfn, ζ = damping ratio, and ẍbase = input acceleration.
Absolute Acceleration Response:
x¨response=x¨base+z¨=−2ζωnz˙−ωn2z
Why Absolute Acceleration?
The SRS plots absolute acceleration because it directly relates to the forces experienced by internal components. For a component of mass m mounted on a resonant structure, the force is F = m·ẍabsolute. Relative displacement z is useful for clearance/sway space analysis, but absolute acceleration determines whether components survive the shock. This is why shock test specifications are written in terms of acceleration SRS—they define the maximum forces that equipment must withstand.
Q Factor & Damping
The quality factor Q defines the sharpness of resonance and is related to damping ratio:
Q=2ζ1
Q Factor
Damping ζ
Application
Q = 10
5%
Standard for pyrotechnic shock (ISO 18431-4, MIL-STD-810)
Q = 25
2%
Lightly damped structures, conservative analysis
Q = 50
1%
Very lightly damped, electronic components
Q = 5
10%
Heavily damped systems, transportation shock
Higher Q = sharper peaks, more conservative SRS. An SRS plot is incomplete without specifying Q.
SRS Types
Type
Definition
Use Case
Maximax
max(|positive|, |negative|) over entire duration
Most common, conservative envelope
Primary
Peak response during shock application
Forced response analysis
Residual
Peak response after shock ends (free vibration)
Ringing/settling analysis
Positive
Maximum positive response
Tensile stress analysis
Negative
Maximum negative response
Compressive stress analysis
Frequency Spacing
SRS frequencies are logarithmically spaced in fractional octave bands:
fk+1=fk⋅21/n
where n = points per octave (e.g., n=6 for 1/6 octave spacing)
Spacing
Points/Octave
Ratio
Application
1/1 Octave
1
2.000
Coarse overview
1/3 Octave
3
1.260
General analysis
1/6 Octave
6
1.122
Standard (ISO 18431-4)
1/12 Octave
12
1.059
Fine resolution
1/24 Octave
24
1.029
High resolution
Selection Guidance: Choose spacing so that the frequency increment is smaller than the half-power bandwidth of the SDOF filter: Δf < fn/Q. For Q=10, 1/6 octave (12.2% spacing) satisfies this for all frequencies.
Sample Rate Requirements
The input time history must be sampled fast enough to accurately capture the shock and compute responses at high frequencies:
Minimum: fs ≥ 10 × fmax (highest SRS frequency)
Recommended: fs ≥ 20 × fmax for accurate peak capture
Example: For SRS to 10 kHz, sample at ≥100 kHz (preferably 200 kHz)
Max SRS Freq
Min Sample Rate
Recommended
Application
2 kHz
20 kHz
40 kHz
Transportation shock
10 kHz
100 kHz
200 kHz
Pyrotechnic shock
100 kHz
1 MHz
2 MHz
Near-field pyroshock
Compensation for Insufficient Sample Rate:
When the sample rate is less than 10× the highest analysis frequency, the digital filter underestimates the true peak response. A correction factor can be applied:
Csr=sinc(πfn/fs)1=sin(πfn/fs)πfn/fs
fs/fn Ratio
Correction Csr
Error if Uncorrected
20
1.004
-0.4%
10
1.017
-1.7%
8
1.026
-2.6%
5
1.067
-6.3%
4
1.111
-10%
3
1.209
-17%
Recommendation: Apply Csr correction when fs/fn < 10. Below ratio of 5, consider resampling/interpolating the time history before SRS calculation for more reliable results. The sinc correction accounts for the averaging effect of discrete sampling on peak values.
Typical Frequency Ranges
Shock Type
Frequency Range
Typical Q
Transportation (drop, handling)
1 Hz – 500 Hz
Q = 5–10
Seismic
0.1 Hz – 100 Hz
Q = 5–10
Pyrotechnic (far-field)
100 Hz – 10 kHz
Q = 10
Pyrotechnic (near-field)
100 Hz – 100 kHz
Q = 10
Ballistic shock
10 Hz – 50 kHz
Q = 10
Velocity & Displacement SRS
SRS can be computed for velocity or displacement by integrating the acceleration response:
Pseudo-Velocity
Vpseudo=ωnAmax=2πfnAmax
Pseudo-Displacement
Dpseudo=ωn2Amax=(2πfn)2Amax
Pseudo-velocity SRS is useful for assessing structural stress (σ ∝ velocity). Tripartite plots show all three on one graph.
50 IPS Shock Severity Threshold
The "50 inches per second" (50 IPS) rule is a widely-used empirical threshold for assessing shock severity and potential for damage:
The 50 IPS Rule: When pseudo-velocity exceeds approximately 50 in/s (1.27 m/s), the shock is considered potentially damaging to typical aerospace/military hardware. This threshold corresponds to stress levels approaching yield in many structural materials.
Pseudo-Velocity
Severity
Typical Concern
< 20 IPS
Low
Generally benign for most equipment
20–50 IPS
Moderate
May cause fatigue damage with repeated exposure
50–100 IPS
High
Potential yield stress in structural elements
> 100 IPS
Severe
Likely permanent deformation or failure
Physical Basis: For a simple beam, bending stress σ ∝ strain rate ∝ velocity. The 50 IPS threshold (~100 dB re 10-6 in/s) empirically correlates with stress levels of 10,000–20,000 psi in aluminum structures, approaching yield for many alloys. This makes pseudo-velocity SRS a direct indicator of damage potential, independent of frequency.
Preprocessing for SRS
Mean Removal
Remove DC offset before processing. DC creates artificial low-frequency content.
Zero Padding
Extend time history with zeros after shock to capture residual response (typically 2× shock duration).
Anti-Alias Filter
Ensure data was acquired with proper anti-aliasing (fc < 0.4 × fs).
Integrity Check
Positive and negative SRS should be similar for symmetric pulses. Large asymmetry may indicate clipping or sensor issues.
Key Insight: Unlike PSD which characterizes stationary random vibration, SRS characterizes transient deterministic events. The SRS is a worst-case envelope—it shows the maximum response that could occur at each frequency, regardless of when it occurs during the event.
Ref: Smallwood "An Improved Recursive Formula for Calculating Shock Response Spectra" Shock & Vibration Bulletin No. 51, 1981; ISO 18431-4:2007 "Shock-response spectrum analysis"; Irvine "An Introduction to the Shock Response Spectrum" Vibrationdata 2012; MIL-STD-810G Method 516.6
Sound Transmission Loss (TL or STL) quantifies the reduction in sound power as it passes through a partition:
TL=10log10(WtransmittedWincident)=10log10(τ1) dB
where τ is the transmission coefficient (ratio of transmitted to incident sound power)
Transmission Loss Regions for Isotropic Panels
The TL behavior of a panel varies with frequency, exhibiting four distinct regions:
Region
Frequency Range
Controlling Factor
TL Behavior
Stiffness Controlled
f < f1 (first resonance)
Panel bending stiffness
TL decreases with frequency
Resonance Region
Near f1
Panel resonances
TL dip at panel modes
Mass Law
f1 < f < fc
Panel surface mass
+6 dB per octave
Coincidence Region
f ≈ fc
Wave matching
TL dip (minimum)
Damping Controlled
f > fc
Internal damping
+9 dB per octave
Mass Law
In the mass-controlled region, TL depends primarily on surface density and frequency:
TLmass=20log10(m′′f)−47.3 dB
where m'' = surface mass density (kg/m²), f = frequency (Hz)
Mass Law Rules of Thumb:
Doubling mass → +6 dB TL
Doubling frequency → +6 dB TL
Field incidence (random) reduces TL by ~5 dB vs. normal incidence
Critical (Coincidence) Frequency
Coincidence occurs when the acoustic wavelength in air matches the bending wavelength in the panel:
fc=2πc2Dρh=2πhc2E12ρ(1−ν2)
where c = speed of sound in air (~343 m/s), h = panel thickness, ρ = panel density, D = bending stiffness, E = Young's modulus, ν = Poisson's ratio
Simplified Formula:
fc≈h12.6Eρ Hz (for steel/aluminum, h in mm)
Material
fc × h (Hz·mm)
1 mm plate fc
10 mm plate fc
Steel
~12,400
12.4 kHz
1.24 kHz
Aluminum
~12,000
12.0 kHz
1.20 kHz
Glass
~12,700
12.7 kHz
1.27 kHz
Plywood
~20,000
20 kHz
2.0 kHz
Gypsum board
~35,000
35 kHz
3.5 kHz
TL at Coincidence
At the critical frequency, TL depends strongly on damping:
TLcoincidence=TLmass+10log10(2η) dB
where η = loss factor. Higher damping reduces the coincidence dip.
Loss Factor η
Coincidence Penalty
Typical Material
0.001
-27 dB
Steel, aluminum
0.01
-17 dB
Glass
0.03
-12 dB
Concrete
0.1
-7 dB
Damped steel
0.3
-2 dB
Heavily damped composite
Above Coincidence (Damping Controlled)
Above the critical frequency, TL increases at approximately 9 dB per octave:
TL=TLmass+10log10(fc2ηf) dB, for f>fc
The 9 dB/octave slope comes from: 6 dB/octave (mass law) + 3 dB/octave (damping term)
First Panel Resonance
For a simply-supported rectangular panel:
f1,1=2πρhD(a21+b21)
where a, b = panel dimensions, D = Eh³/12(1-ν²) = bending stiffness
Design Strategies
Strategy
Effect on TL
Trade-offs
Increase mass
+6 dB per doubling
Weight penalty
Add damping
Reduces coincidence dip
Cost, weight
Double-wall construction
+12 dB/octave above mass-air-mass resonance
Thickness, complexity
Constrained layer damping
Raises TL at/above fc
Weight, cost
Sandwich construction
Shifts fc lower, higher stiffness
Complex coincidence behavior
Double-Wall Construction
Double-wall partitions provide significantly higher TL than single walls of equivalent mass by decoupling the two panels with an air gap.
Mass-Air-Mass Resonance
The air gap acts as a spring between the two panel masses, creating a resonance at:
f0=2π1dρairc2(m11+m21)
where d = air gap depth, m₁, m₂ = panel surface masses (kg/m²), ρair ≈ 1.21 kg/m³, c ≈ 343 m/s
TL Behavior by Frequency Region
Region
Frequency Range
TL Behavior
Below f₀
f < f₀
Follows combined mass law (~6 dB/octave)
At Resonance
f ≈ f₀
TL dip (panels move in phase)
Above f₀
f > f₀
~12 dB/octave (6 dB mass + 6 dB decoupling)
Simplified Double-Wall TL (above f₀)
TLdouble≈TL1+TL2+20log10(f0f) dB
where TL₁, TL₂ = individual panel mass law TL values
Design Guidelines
Parameter
Effect
Recommendation
Air gap depth
Larger d → lower f₀
Maximize gap (50-100 mm typical)
Panel mass ratio
Dissimilar masses broaden improvement
Use different thicknesses/materials
Cavity absorption
Reduces cavity resonances
Add fiberglass/mineral wool
Structural bridges
Short-circuit decoupling
Minimize rigid connections
Edge sealing
Flanking paths reduce TL
Seal all gaps and penetrations
Example: Two 3 mm aluminum panels (m = 8.1 kg/m² each) with 50 mm air gap: f₀ ≈ 84 Hz. At 1 kHz, double-wall provides ~25 dB more TL than a single 6 mm panel of the same total mass.
Key Insight: For aerospace applications, the coincidence frequency often falls within the critical frequency range (100 Hz – 10 kHz). Designing panels with fc above the frequency range of interest, or adding sufficient damping to mitigate the coincidence dip, is essential for achieving target TL performance. For maximum TL, consider double-wall construction with the mass-air-mass resonance below the frequency range of interest.
Ref: Fahy & Gardonio "Sound and Structural Vibration" 2nd Ed. Academic Press 2007; Cremer, Heckl & Petersson "Structure-Borne Sound" 3rd Ed. Springer 2005; Beranek & Vér "Noise and Vibration Control Engineering" 2nd Ed. Wiley 2006; ISO 10140 "Acoustics - Laboratory measurement of sound insulation"
Insertion Loss (IL) quantifies the reduction in sound pressure level at a receiver location due to the insertion of an acoustic treatment (barrier, enclosure, silencer):
IL=Lp,before−Lp,after dB
where Lp,before = SPL without treatment, Lp,after = SPL with treatment
Barrier Insertion Loss
Sound barriers reduce noise by blocking the direct path and forcing sound to diffract over the top edge.
Fresnel Number
The key parameter for barrier performance is the Fresnel number:
N=λ2δ=c2δf
where δ = path length difference (A+B-d), λ = wavelength, f = frequency, c = speed of sound
Path Difference Geometry
δ = A + B - d
A = source to barrier top, B = barrier top to receiver, d = direct path (source to receiver)
Maekawa's Empirical Formula
For a thin, rigid barrier with N > 0 (receiver in shadow zone):
IL=10log10(3+20N) dB
Valid for 0.01 ≤ N ≤ 12.5, point source, no ground reflections
ISO 9613-2 Barrier Formula
More accurate formula accounting for ground and meteorological effects:
IL=10log10(3+λC2⋅C3⋅z⋅Kmet) dB
where z = path difference, C₂ = 20 (single diffraction), C₃ = 1 for single edge, Kmet = meteorological correction
Fresnel Number N
IL (Maekawa)
Typical Application
0.01
5 dB
Grazing incidence
0.1
8 dB
Low barrier
1.0
13 dB
Moderate barrier
10
23 dB
High barrier, high frequency
100
33 dB
Very effective barrier
Enclosure Insertion Loss
Acoustic enclosures surround a noise source to contain radiated sound.
Ideal Enclosure (No Leaks)
IL=TL+10log10(RSenclosure) dB
where TL = transmission loss of enclosure walls, S = enclosure surface area, R = room constant of interior
Simplified Enclosure IL
For enclosures with internal absorption:
IL≈TL−10log10(1+αˉSS(1−αˉ)) dB
where ᾱ = average absorption coefficient inside enclosure
Enclosure Type
Typical IL
Notes
Light sheet metal (no absorption)
10-15 dB
Limited by internal reverb
Sheet metal + internal lining
15-25 dB
2" fiberglass typical
Double-wall with absorption
25-40 dB
High-performance
Lead-lined/composite
35-50 dB
Critical applications
Silencer/Muffler Insertion Loss
Silencers attenuate sound in ducts and exhaust systems through reactive and dissipative mechanisms.
Dissipative Silencer (Lined Duct)
Attenuation per unit length for rectangular duct with absorptive lining:
IL=1.05⋅S0.5α1.4⋅P⋅L dB
where α = absorption coefficient, P = lined perimeter, S = open area, L = length
Reactive Silencer (Expansion Chamber)
Simple expansion chamber transmission loss:
TL=10log10[1+41(m−m1)2sin2(kL)] dB
where m = S₂/S₁ = expansion ratio, k = 2πf/c = wavenumber, L = chamber length
Silencer Type
Mechanism
Typical IL
Best For
Lined duct
Dissipative
3-10 dB/m
Mid-high frequency
Expansion chamber
Reactive
5-25 dB (tuned)
Low frequency tones
Helmholtz resonator
Reactive
10-30 dB (narrow band)
Specific frequencies
Combination
Both
15-40 dB
Broadband + tones
Design Guidelines
Treatment
Key Design Factor
Common Pitfall
Barriers
Maximize path difference δ
Flanking paths around ends
Enclosures
Seal all gaps, add internal absorption
Leaks dominate at high TL
Silencers
Match to frequency content
Flow noise regeneration
Key Insight: Insertion loss is always measured or predicted for a specific source-receiver geometry. Unlike TL (a material property), IL depends on the entire acoustic path including reflections, flanking, and source directivity. Always verify predicted IL with field measurements when possible.
Ref: Maekawa, Z. "Noise Reduction by Screens" Applied Acoustics 1968; ISO 9613-2 "Acoustics - Attenuation of sound during propagation outdoors"; Beranek & Vér "Noise and Vibration Control Engineering" 2nd Ed. Wiley 2006; Bies & Hansen "Engineering Noise Control" 5th Ed. CRC Press 2017
25. FEA Best Practices for Dynamic Analysis
Guidance for building FE models from CAD for modal and modal transient analysis.
Element Type Selection
Structure Type
Recommended Element
Notes
Thin-walled (t/L < 0.1)
CQUAD4, CTRIA3
Shell elements capture bending efficiently
Thick structures
CHEXA, CPENTA
Use when t/L > 0.1 or 3D stress needed
Slender members
CBAR, CBEAM
L/d > 10; include shear deformation for short beams
Stiffeners on panels
CBEAM on shell
Offset to mid-plane; check eccentricity
Fastener patterns
CBUSH, CFAST
Avoid over-stiffening with RBE2
Linear vs. Quadratic: Linear elements (CQUAD4) are preferred for dynamics—faster solve, adequate accuracy with proper mesh density. Quadratic (CQUAD8) needed only for curved geometry or stress accuracy.
Composite Modeling
Card
Use Case
Key Inputs
PCOMP
Standard layup
MIDi, Ti, THETAi per ply; Z0 offset
PCOMPG
Global ply IDs
Same as PCOMP + global ply tracking
MAT8
Orthotropic 2D
E1, E2, G12, NU12, RHO
Define fiber direction (0°) consistently—typically along primary load path
Use symmetric layups to avoid bend-twist coupling artifacts
For equivalent smeared properties: use [A], [B], [D] matrices from CLT
Joint Modeling
Joint Type
Modeling Approach
Stiffness Guidance
Bolted (stiff)
RBE2 or CBUSH
K ≈ E·A/L for axial; include preload effects
Bolted (flexible)
CBUSH with K, B
Huth/Swift formula for shear flexibility
Bonded
Tied contact or RBE2
Assume rigid unless adhesive layer modeled
Spot welds
CWELD, CFAST
Diameter-based stiffness; check nugget size
Interference fit
CBUSH radial
K = p·π·d·L/δ (pressure-based)
RBE2 (Rigid): All dependent DOFs slaved to independent node. Over-stiffens locally—use sparingly.
RBE3 (Interpolation): Distributes loads/motion. Does NOT add stiffness. Good for load application.
WTMASS converts density units: ρinternal=WTMASS×ρinput
Parameter
Purpose
Recommended
AUTOSPC
Auto-constrain singularities
YES (review .f06 for warnings)
MAXRATIO
Max stiffness ratio check
1.0E7 (default); lower for ill-conditioned
BAILOUT
Stop on singularity
-1 (stop) for debugging
RESVEC
Residual vectors
YES for modal methods with concentrated loads
COUPMASS
Coupled mass matrix
1 for rotational inertia accuracy
Model Simplifications
Non-Structural Mass (NSM) Add mass without stiffness for paint, insulation, wiring. Use NSM field on PSHELL/PCOMP or CONM2 elements.
Symmetry BCs Constrain out-of-plane translation and in-plane rotations at symmetry plane. Halves model size.
Mass Lumping (CONM2) Represent equipment as point masses. Include moments of inertia (I11, I22, I33) for large items.
Substructuring Use superelements for repeated components or supplier-provided reduced models.
Model Checkout Checklist
Check
Method
What to Look For
Free-Free Modes
SOL 103, no SPCs
6 rigid body modes < 1 Hz (ideally < 0.01 Hz); 7th mode is 1st flex
Mass Properties
GPWG output
Total mass, CG location, MOI vs. CAD/hand calc (within 1-2%)
Strain Energy
ESE output
Identify elements with high strain energy; check for stress concentrations
Grid Point Singularity
AUTOSPC output
Review constrained DOFs; may indicate missing connections
Epsilon Check
EPSILON in .f06
Should be < 1E-8; larger values indicate numerical issues
Max/Min Checks
MAXMIN output
Extreme values may indicate bad elements or units
1g Static Load
SOL 101, GRAV card
Reaction forces = total weight; deflection reasonable
Key Insight: A well-checked model with simple elements often outperforms a complex model with poor mesh quality. Prioritize mesh convergence studies on the first few modes before adding complexity.
Ref: MSC Nastran Linear Static Analysis User's Guide; Cook et al. "Concepts and Applications of Finite Element Analysis" Wiley 2001; NASA-STD-5002 "Structural Design and Test Factors of Safety"; Altair Practical Aspects of FEA
26. Craig-Bampton Component Mode Synthesis
Model reduction technique for efficient dynamic analysis of large, complex assemblies.
Theory Overview
Craig-Bampton (CB) reduces a component's DOFs to boundary DOFs plus a truncated set of fixed-interface normal modes. The transformation preserves dynamic behavior at interfaces while dramatically reducing model size.
Fixed-Interface Normal Modes (Φ) Eigenvectors from SOL 103 with boundary DOFs fixed (SPC). Capture internal dynamics of component.
Constraint Modes (Ψ) Static shapes from unit displacement at each boundary DOF. Capture quasi-static coupling between components.
Governing Equations
Original system partitioned into boundary (b) and interior (i) DOFs:
Residual vectors augment the CB basis to improve accuracy for loads not well-represented by truncated modes.
Why Needed: Truncated modes may miss response to concentrated loads or high-frequency content. Residual vectors span the "missing" subspace.
Implementation: PARAM RESVEC YES in Nastran. Automatically computes static response to applied loads and orthogonalizes against mode set.
Residual vector for load {F}:
{r}=[K]−1{F}−i=1∑nωi2{ϕi}T{F}{ϕi}
Captures static response not spanned by retained modes
Modal Truncation Guidelines
Analysis Type
Frequency Cutoff
Rationale
Frequency Response
1.5-2× fmax
Ensures modes near upper frequency are accurate
Transient (shock)
2-3× fmax
Higher modes contribute to peak response
Random Vibration
1.5× fmax
RMS dominated by resonances within band
Mode Participation: Check modal effective mass. Retain modes until cumulative effective mass > 90% in each direction. Low effective mass modes may be truncated even if within frequency range.
Component Coupling
Reduced components are assembled at shared boundary DOFs:
Key Insight: CB reduction is exact for static loads and increasingly accurate as more modes are retained. The constraint modes ensure perfect static response; errors arise only from modal truncation of dynamic content. Always verify with back-expansion at critical locations.
Ref: Craig & Bampton "Coupling of Substructures for Dynamic Analyses" AIAA J. 1968; MSC Nastran Superelement User's Guide; de Klerk et al. "General Framework for Dynamic Substructuring" AIAA J. 2008; Rixen "A Dual Craig-Bampton Method" M2AN 2004
27. Dimensionless Parameters
Dimensionless parameters enable similarity analysis, scaling between test and flight, and characterization of physical phenomena. They are ratios of competing physical effects.
Reynolds Number (Re)
Ratio of inertial forces to viscous forces. Determines flow regime (laminar vs turbulent).
Re=μρVL=νVL
ρ = fluid density, V = velocity, L = characteristic length
μ = dynamic viscosity, ν = kinematic viscosity
Re Range
Flow Regime
Application
Re<2,300
Laminar (pipe)
Viscous-dominated, predictable
2,300<Re<4,000
Transitional
Intermittent turbulence
Re>4,000
Turbulent (pipe)
Inertia-dominated, chaotic
Rex≈5×105
Flat plate transition
Boundary layer transition
Mach Number (M)
Ratio of flow velocity to local speed of sound. Determines compressibility effects.
M=cV=γRTV
c = speed of sound, γ = ratio of specific heats (1.4 for air)
R = specific gas constant, T = absolute temperature
Mach Range
Regime
Characteristics
M<0.3
Incompressible
Density changes <5%, use Bernoulli
0.3<M<0.8
Subsonic
Compressibility corrections needed
0.8<M<1.2
Transonic
Mixed sub/supersonic, shocks form
1.2<M<5
Supersonic
Shock waves, expansion fans
M>5
Hypersonic
High-temp effects, dissociation
Strouhal Number (St)
Ratio of oscillatory inertia to convective inertia. Characterizes vortex shedding and unsteady flows.
St=VfL
f = shedding frequency (Hz), L = characteristic length (diameter)
V = flow velocity
Vortex Shedding: For cylinders in crossflow, St≈0.2 over 300<Re<2×105. Use to predict lock-in frequencies: f=St⋅V/D
Geometry
St Value
Re Range
Circular cylinder
0.18 - 0.22
300−2×105
Square cylinder
0.12 - 0.14
103−105
Flat plate (normal)
0.14 - 0.15
104−105
Sphere
0.18 - 0.20
103−105
Helmholtz Number (He)
Ratio of characteristic length to acoustic wavelength. Determines acoustic compactness.
He≈1: Resonance region (cavity modes, Helmholtz resonators)
He≫1: Geometric acoustics (ray tracing valid)
Other Key Parameters
Parameter
Definition
Physical Meaning
Typical Use
Knudsen (Kn)
Kn=λmfp/L
Mean free path / length
Continuum vs rarefied flow
Prandtl (Pr)
Pr=ν/α=cpμ/k
Momentum / thermal diffusivity
Heat transfer (Pr ≈ 0.7 for air)
Nusselt (Nu)
Nu=hL/k
Convective / conductive heat
Heat transfer coefficient
Froude (Fr)
Fr=V/gL
Inertia / gravity
Free surface flows, ships
Weber (We)
We=ρV2L/σ
Inertia / surface tension
Droplets, sprays, bubbles
Womersley (Wo)
Wo=Lω/ν
Unsteady / viscous
Pulsatile flow (blood, hydraulics)
Reduced Freq (k)
k=ωc/(2V)
Unsteadiness parameter
Aeroelasticity, flutter
Knudsen Number Regimes
Kn Range
Regime
Modeling Approach
Kn<0.01
Continuum
Navier-Stokes, no-slip BC
0.01<Kn<0.1
Slip flow
N-S with slip BC
0.1<Kn<10
Transitional
DSMC, Boltzmann
Kn>10
Free molecular
Collisionless kinetic theory
Similarity Principle: Two flows are dynamically similar if all relevant dimensionless parameters match. For aeroacoustics: match Re, M, St. For scaling: if geometry scales by λ, maintain same Re and M to preserve flow physics.
Ref: White "Viscous Fluid Flow" 3rd ed. 2006; Anderson "Fundamentals of Aerodynamics" 6th ed. 2017; Blevins "Flow-Induced Vibration" 2nd ed. 1990; Kinsler et al. "Fundamentals of Acoustics" 4th ed. 2000; Schlichting & Gersten "Boundary-Layer Theory" 9th ed. 2017
Constant Percentage Bandwidth: Octave bands have constant percentage bandwidth (not constant Hz). For 1/3 octave: Δf/fc=21/3−2−1/3≈23%. This matches human auditory frequency resolution (critical bands).
NC curves are used to rate background noise in occupied spaces, particularly for HVAC system design. Each curve represents a maximum acceptable SPL at each octave band.
NC Curves (ASHRAE)
Determining NC Rating: Plot measured octave band spectrum on NC curves. The NC rating equals the highest NC curve touched or exceeded by any band in the measured spectrum.
Recommended NC Levels by Space Type
Space Type
NC Range
Notes
Concert halls, recording studios
NC-15 to NC-20
Critical listening environments
Theaters, courtrooms
NC-20 to NC-30
Speech intelligibility critical
Private offices, conference rooms
NC-30 to NC-35
Confidential speech privacy
Open offices, lobbies
NC-35 to NC-45
Normal speech communication
Retail, restaurants
NC-40 to NC-50
Background masking acceptable
Kitchens, laundries, factories
NC-50 to NC-65
High ambient noise expected
Related Rating Systems
RC (Room Criteria)
Improved version addressing rumble (R) and hiss (H) imbalance. Includes quality descriptors.
NR (Noise Rating)
European/ISO equivalent. Similar shape but different values. NR ≈ NC + 5 approximately.
Ref: ASHRAE Handbook - HVAC Applications Ch. 48; ANSI/ASA S12.2-2008 "Criteria for Evaluating Room Noise"; ISO 1996-1 "Acoustics - Description and measurement of environmental noise"
Mode shapes describe the spatial pattern of vibration at each natural frequency. Understanding mode shapes is essential for predicting structural response to dynamic loads and designing effective vibration control.
1D Beam Mode Shapes (Euler-Bernoulli)
For a uniform beam with bending stiffness EI, mass per unit length ρA, and length L, the mode shapes depend on boundary conditions:
Simply-supported beam: first four mode shapes showing nodal points
Simply-Supported (Pinned-Pinned)
Both ends free to rotate but constrained against translation.
ϕn(x)=sin(Lnπx)
fn=2L2n2πρAEI=2πL2(nπ)2ρAEI
Symbol
Description
Units
ϕn(x)
Mode shape function (normalized displacement pattern)
dimensionless
n
Mode number (1, 2, 3, ...)
integer
x
Position along beam
m or in
L
Beam length
m or in
fn
Natural frequency of mode n
Hz
E
Young's modulus
Pa or psi
I
Area moment of inertia
m⁴ or in⁴
ρ
Material density
kg/m³ or lb/in³
A
Cross-sectional area
m² or in²
Frequency Ratios: f₁ : f₂ : f₃ : f₄ = 1 : 4 : 9 : 16 (proportional to n²)
Clamped-Clamped (Fixed-Fixed)
Both ends constrained against rotation and translation.